gaianeconomics.blogspot.com.br/2007/10/competing-definitions-of-free-market.html
Competing definitions of a free market
The Competition Commission has found
that supermarkets serve customers well. According to the limited
economistic, marketistic mindset from which they see the world this
is actually the correct conclusion. It is that mindset, and its
political support, that we need to unpick in order to understand how
they could have arrived at this frankly shocking conclusion.
The problem we face is that, as a
society, we are undergoing a paradigm shift. For those of us living
in the sustainable world of the future, diversity means a range of
types of shopping, different shops or makers selling subtly different
versions of the same product, or whose ownership structure or style
suits our value system. To the Competition Commission diversity means
four monocultural shopping outlets within which you can buy a range
of 100 different fish all of which taste of very little. If you only
have one of these you lack competition; if you have two the free
market is functioning well for you.
For the proponents of supermarkets they
are efficient places
because you can buy everything you need as quickly as possible for as
little time as possible, allowing you more time to make money to buy
more. As a capitalist production-and-consumption unit supermarkets
allow you to be as efficient as
possible. The fact that they rely on
global agribusiness which uses 10 calories of energy to make 1
calorie of food (according to Richard Heinberg) does nothing to
undermine their claims to efficiency.
Although such reports can lead to
unhealthy gnashing and grinding of teeth the real problem is a
political one. We are building the new, sustainable,
community-focused world we want to live in. Nowhere is this more
evident that in the area of food, where most greenies use an
alternative system of wholefood shops or have their own wholefood
co-op. The producers and distributors, many organised as
co-operatives themselves, provide a parallel food economy based on
the values of the future.
No comments:
Post a Comment